Storage solutions: Dave Walsh of Card Talk

It’s safe to say that I was taken by surprise by this game.  I entered in April 2014 and after a year of dabbling in the game, I realized that I wanted to get everything, NOW!  I very quickly outgrew my old core set box, the staple of game storage from the the onset. This lead to a few logistical concerns, not the least of which was how I was going to store the game and keep it organized.

My Spirit Binder

The hardest part for me were not the player cards.  Those are in binders organized by sphere, then by Hero, Ally, Attachment, and Event.  As the player card pool expands, it’s easy enough to get more nine-pocket sheets and expand the notebooks with ease.   The hardest part was the encounter cards.  Trying to keep them organized so that I could easily get the encounter deck put together and on the table proved insanely difficult for me.

My first attempt at encounter card storage came, as I gather happens with most players, with clear plastic bags.  The hobby stores sell these in bulk and are cheap.  I ended up using snack size bags from the grocery store to achieve the same purpose.  I then threw all my encounter sets into a plastic shoe box.  As I expanded quickly, it soon became two plastic shoe boxes.  The problem I found is that I couldn’t easily grab the encounter sets because they were all mixed up.  And do you know how many funny hill-looking encounter set icons the game has that all look alike?!  Yikes!  Let’s not even talk about the goblin-face icons.

                  The Lord of the Rings: The Mountain of Fire Saga Expansion

Encounter card sets stored in my 1600 card vertical storage box.

So enter the vertical 1600 card storage box.  This box is holding me over until I get all the cycle boxes that have made the rounds on Facebook and Discord.  Two boxes fit all the encounter cards that I have, which is everything but nightmare for the Heirs of Numenor box and beyond.  The dividers are 3×5 plain white index cards. I printed out all the encounter set symbols that were available at the time, cut them out and taped them using packing tape to the index card.  This is the file of encounter card symbols.  It has done me well and I love how easy it is to flip through and find the right encounter set for the scenario I’m playing.  Also, as a bonus, LOTR LCG cards are thinner than sports cards, so I found that the boxes held more than the 1600 cards it said.  I used the extra space in the card boxes to store sleeves, player decks, some pre-built encounter scenarios and my tokens and dice.  The extra space was great!

The happy accident that happened because of this system is that I needed a way to get a hold of a scenario quickly in a way that I could recognize which scenario is which.  So, I


made a 2″ binder with all the rules inserts AND the quest cards for the non-saga expansions and a 1.5″ binder for the saga expansions.  I found larger page tabs to label the cycles and smaller tabs to identify the difficulty of each quest.  The rules inserts were taken apart if they were multiple pages and each page was placed in a plastic, 3-ring page protector.  With the quest cards in the same place as the rules, it helps when there are special mechanics in a quest that I need to remind myself of.  I typically grab the quest cards and look over the rules insert for the scenario before I startIMG_1440 playing.

The down side to this, and I’m not sure if it’s enough of a down side to get me to stop doing it, is that the quest cards aren’t with the encounter cards. That means that when I am toting my cards around the countryside, every once in a while I find myself with encounter cards and no quest cards or vice-versa. And that’s a bummer.  Another down side for those who love to sleeve EVERYTHING, is that I don’t sleeve my quest cards and the 9 pocket plastic sheet doesn’t really lend itself to storing sleeved cards.

Since I have stepped up my LOTR LCG game and I find myself collecting the game more and more (like buying alt art cards and playmats), the 1600-card storage box just isn’t glamorous. Trust me, it’s very utilitarian and I can fit both boxes in one multi-use grocery bag, but it’s just not sexy.  IMG_1437Enter the internet.  I found that someone posted beautiful, custom card boxes for each scenario. They graciously shared their art with me and now I have an almost one of a kind storage box for my encounter cards that makes the game even more amazing.  So, here’s how to get your hands on these boxes for most of the game.  The art for each cycle and for the sagas is stored here.  Download which ever art you are interested in.  Then, go on over the and look up the custom 500 count deck box, or just use this link.  Choose what kind of finish you want (I chose matte, linen) and then upload the art file.  In a week or so, you’ll have your storage box.  I wish I could take any credit for these boxes, but credit goes to GeckoTH for their original design.  The community has expanded the art and the only thing I have done is consolidated it into one place with the hopes of keeping it up-to-date.

One thing that I wanted to make sure of it that the box fit all the regular and nightmare cards of the cycle, sleeved with penny sleeves.  And, they do.  It turns out that the Dwarrowdelf cycle had a few more encounter cards and it’s a tight fit, but it fits none the less.  The penny sleeves I use are these. MirkwoodThe dividers are interesting because I needed dividers that folded down on the cards so the box closes.  So I found these dividers. And I like them.  I don’t love them, but they work.  I’ve also decided that I have no need to label the dividers because I put the sets in order of the set icons on the side of the box.  If I need a certain encounter set, I can find it pretty easily with this system. Additional art for the dividers can be found here if you are looking to upgrade your divider system. 

IMG_1441At this point, I have a pretty great way of organizing and storing my cards.  But I have to say that the last piece of the puzzle is the deck box swag that Cardboard of the Rings gave away last year.  The box has three removable smaller boxes which will hold a deck of 60 cards, sleeved with these sleeves.  The other bonus is that they store about 110 cards unsleeved.  That means when I am in my deck construction mode, before I finalize my deck, I can put two decks in a box.  It’s great.

As you see, my storage solution for this game has gone through some growing pains.  I think that now I have a solution that is elegant and will grow as the game grows.  Also, if you have any questions about this, please send me an email to


(Images by Dave Walsh and Johnny McRae)

Boxes for cycles 1, 6, and 7
Side view of the boxes
Dividers with art that fit into the boxes perfectly

14 thoughts on “Storage solutions: Dave Walsh of Card Talk

  1. Thank you for sharing this, especially the box maker link. I love the Storage Solutions topic in this blog.

    All the files I’ve seen online (including your link) for the Return of the King box bottom has one of the images inverted – the 3 panel with Gandalf, Barad-Dur/Eye, and Gollum/Frodo at crack of Mt Doom. When folded up – this image would be “upside down” on the box bottom. The Eye of Sauron on the right side also might be inverted (I think the “heat” emanating from the eye should face the top, not the bottom of the box.

    Has anyone else noticed this, and created a corrected version?


    1. I haven’t noticed and no one else has. I’ll take a look and see what I can do. I’m not sure if I have the software to do anything about it though. But thanks for pointing it out!


      1. I rebuilt the ROTK Saga box bottom to correct the fold up error.

        While I was at it, I replaced the top art with the Flame of the West cover, moved Mountain of Fire to the bottom, replaced bottom images so “heads aren’t cut off” on the folds, redid scenario fonts to Windlass to match rest of box (and corrected Pelennor spelling), redid scenario background with a backdrop map of Middle Earth where the events occurred….

        One thing led to another, and now I have almost half of the 13 beautiful GeckoTH style boxes found in various places redone in consistent format, with intent to finish and print the rest. Your article really inspired me on this!

        Another question for you – you used “matte, linen” on the boxes from, but most of the images (e.g. top of Dreamchasers, Mirkwood, etc.) look “glossy, smooth” to me. I note the side of the bottom of the Mirkwood box does look matte. Is this a camera quirk, or an indication of the quality and consistency of the boxes?


        P.S. I really appreciate all the effort you put into the LOTR LCG community and your Card Talk Series.


    2. Mark, I saw in your reply below that you have an updated version of the ROTK box image as well as some other updates. Would you be willing to post those up somewhere? Did you actually get the boxes printed at If so, how did they turn out?


  2. thanks for this…looks like such an elegant solution but i priced out just the cycle boxes and i think it’s a little too rich for my blood. really great of you to post though and keep up the good works!! 🙂


    Liked by 1 person

  3. sorry, where you find Dividers and Boxes files? Left Storage of shadows in the east and related cycle.
    And left diveders of Ered Mithrin like the Others.
    It is possible ?


  4. I’m hoping to order a set of these soon!I was thinking on your need for the “lay down” divider cards so the tops fit. Have you explored tacking in a small piece of soft foam to the inside corners (along the short ends from side to side) of the tops?

    This might keep the lid up just enough, though it would take away any stacking ability most likely.


  5. They are fabulous. Does anyone know where to get the psd files? I would like to do the Spanish version


  6. Looks awesome!

    Since everything is coming to an end, do you consider to add the the final cycle cover print? Further I noticed that there are Nightmare boxes in the original thread which are not in google drive of this article. Do you expect any update on those as well?

    Really looking forward to implement this artwork into my near-to-complete collection.

    Keep up the good work!


  7. I tried to upload the art file but a message popped up that said they only accept PDF, Ai and PSD file types, and the art files are png. I’ve never tried something like this before, so was I supposed to do something with the files first?


  8. I had the same issue with uploading the artwork for ordering the boxes.
    So instead of ordering the boxes, I figured these can also be made DYI quite easily.
    I had the artwork printed on 2x A3 sticker paper at a local copyshop (using a scaling factor of 115% to get the boxes in the correct size).
    Then create the boxes yourself from some thin cardboard (1 mm thick).
    Once the boxes are made, stick on the artwork and all is done.
    All in all approximately 1-2 hours work to create a complete box for 5-10 Euros a piece.


  9. Just discovered this post almost four years later… The company told me they can’t print due to copyright regulations. Did you not face that or did you send a particular answer?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s