With Bellach’s Orcs scouring the country around Tharbad
looking for the Dwarf, Nalir, the heroes had chosen to flee with
him into the Nîn-in-Eilph, a vast swampland that had been
undisturbed for ages.— The Nîn-in-Eilph insert
Cycle: The Ring-maker Cycle Adventure Pack 4
Week 43/44, 2026.
One of the sloggiest quests, and not just because you’re in a swamp.
The Nîn-in-Eilph’s Stats
- Groups registered: 9
- Total attempts: 14
- Most attempts: 3
- Average attempts per entry: 1.6
- Official difficulty: 4/10
- Community-rated difficulty: 7.1/10

- Total number of wins: 8
- Average win-rate: 64.8%

- Average opinion on the quest: 3.0
Nîn-in-Eilph regularly ranks near the bottom of most polls, often for good reason. This quest can be brutal and unforgiving in the worst of times and a slog in the best of times. It’s currently rated the third-worst encounter in the cycle for Quest of the Week.


Achievements
The achievements in Nîn-in-Eilph challenge you to sprint past the pain and dispatch a certain swamp-dweller multiple times.
I Know a Shortcut is for those who really know how to walk on water (or mud). If you can manage to finish off the quest stage before the final time counter is removed then you’ve either solved this quest’s puzzle or have some lucky encounter pulls!
Is That All of Them? is a little easier to accomplish in Nightmare where you face the Ancient Marsh-dweller from the beginning of the game, but if you’ve managed to kill it in stage 3 before it’s brought back a second time in stage 4 then you have an easy achievement on your hands.
I Know a Shortcut
Complete the first stage 2B and 3B revealed before the last time counter is removed from that stage.
Is That All of Them?
Complete the scenario where you defeat the Ancient Marsh-dweller twice.

Encounter Card Opinions
The Favorite
Islands in rivers, also known as “eyots” (or “aits” depending), were the clear sign of refuge in this never-ending morass of snakes and dwellers. Clearing 4 quest points gets you 2 time counters placed back on the quest.

Special shout-out to the Ancient Marsh-dweller!
Why so much hate agains it? It is a great boss! Recurrying and growths
The Least-favorite
As with other quests, the least favorite for Nîn-in-Eilph was our dear friend, Nalir.

What more can be said about this opportunistic dwarf other than he should’ve been left in the swamp.
Things worth sharing from the games
Started on the quest that didn’t allow draw and resources, which sucked for a deck with Theodred and many thinner cards, next was the “play only 1 card” stage which also was bad, but returning to the first one I managed to power through thanks to Faramir appearing in my hand. I got to the “only stand 5 characters”-stage Low on Provisions in 2 turns after another killed a good portion of my ally-swarm but Gaffer managed to tell that Marsh-Dweller to stay off his lawn and Narya on Halbarad + Hammersmith and some more ready characters could bring the boss down in 2 rounds. Honestly, this one game I played for it managed to keep me from rating this quest a 1. I had fun with that deck.
I didn’t hate the quest. That’s the best I can really say about it. It’s very thematic, and the art is fun. I also ran into all the quest stages that actually were painful, and none of those that I wouldn’t care about. I treated Erestor’s card draw as altering a framework effect for No End in Sight, but not being able to use Elven-Light and my Steward of Gondor or Arwen was painful. And only being able to play one card per round? Not a fun effect at all.
The first game I was cruising along looking good until Shifting Marshland caused Beravor to die (thanks to In Need of Rest) before I could heal her. I forsaw the death coming and used her ability to draw and then played Daeron’s Runes before I lost Lore access. Unfortunately that meant I also couldn’t use Ioreth to heal anymore and the second Low on Provisions reveal wiped my board. The second game went much better. I won without much fanfare. I drew the 2B that makes you discard a card to commit to the quest which only stuck for the first round thanks to Shifting Marshland and Off Track being revealed turn 1. I got the one that prohibits card draw and resource generation next which was no bid deal for my BoF deck. Tactics Eowyn’s ability was used to defeat the AMD at stage 3B and then I had my board build up just enound to take him out again on the turn I advanced to stage 4B. Erkenbrand was defending for 6 thanks to Gondorian Shield, Ally Arwen, and Hauberk of Mail so attacks from the AMD were no bid deal. I actually kind of like this quest.
Played it again the right way, where Cirdan and Erestor’s draw are both completely shut down by No End in Sight (but their forced discard isn’t…). That means that stage is pretty deadly for my Noldor deck. My first run ended in a loss, got the stage that only allowed me to play one card each round, then No End in Sight with my increasing threat and poor board state. Played again and got A Weary Passage, which is perfect for Noldor. Started with Hidden Eyot in play and got extra time on that stage, which allowed me to build up and then move to stage 3. From there it wasn’t bad, Unexpected Courage, Narya, Light of Valinor, ally Glorfindel all help with A Treacherous Swamp. Killed the Ancient Marsh-Dweller twice. I really can’t pinpoint why (could be the art, could be the Ancient Marsh-Dweller, which I think is a cool boss), but I ended up liking this quest, even though the random stage 2s can just result in a scoop. I probably won’t be playing again soon, but I had fun with it.
I played with a deck that gave Gimli 12 max health, so he hit for 11 damage on his own. After putting a Dunedain Cache on him he was able to knock out the AMD every time it came out of the victory display. Having Elrond and several Wardens kept the table topped up where a small ally wasn’t available for sacrifice to the Swamp Adder.
As a first time player for this quest, I found I enjoyed it more than its reputation led me to believe I would. Don’t get me wrong, some of the Stage 2Bs are ridiculous, but I found that packing a ton of willpower (thank you, Dain) just helped push through them. I like that this quest presented a deck building puzzle in a better fashion than some of the earlier cycles did in pushing certain decks. First loss was a quick scoop due pulling A Forgotten Land, which effectively shut down the Dwarf Swarm. Second game I managed to avoid that one, spam allies to the board (ending with 13), and power through to a win.
Only managed to try the quest once with the Beorn, Elrond, Eowyn deck featuring Eagles, and ultimately succumbed to the bogs and marsh. The deck was just a bit too slow to get moving in the willpower department for this quest.
The cycle progression Silvans made their way through the muck to victory. The classic pairing of Celeborn’s willpower boost plus Nenya/Galadriel got me through the questing pushes. Made sure to hang on to one Feigned Voices for the end, then between Sneak/Gandalf, Celeborn, and a few Mirkwood Runners, was able to take down the Marsh-dweller in one round.
I like this quest! It punishes you for turtling in a fair way; If you take things slow, it fights back with the same weapons, escalating in power against you.
Decklists Used
Noldor https://ringsdb.com/decklist/view/68414/nulled-orenull-door-1.0
BOF Beravor, Eowyn, Glorfindel, and Erkenbrand
https://ringsdb.com/deck/view/581051
Noldor https://ringsdb.com/decklist/view/68414/nulled-orenull-door-1.0
Gandalf/Merry/Gimli
Galadriel/Arwen/Elrond
Cycle Progression Dwarves: Dain, Nori, Ori (https://ringsdb.com/deck/view/699061)
Cycle Progression Vilya: Beorn, Elrond, Eowyn (https://ringsdb.com/deck/view/699591)
Cycle Progression Silvans: Bifur, Celeborn, Galadriel (https://ringsdb.com/deck/view/699056)
Bree, Gimli and Gloin BOF – https://ringsdb.com/deck/view/621794
If you haven’t yet voted on the difficulty of the quest over at the LOTR LCG Quest Companion, feel free to do so here: The Nîn-in-Eilph on the LOTR Quest Companion
For the next quest in the cycle, you can submit your playthrough of Celebrimbor’s Secret using the form here: https://forms.gle/1HUgaY413dwM4S7D7.
If you want to share in the discussion of this quest live, join the Cardboard of the Rings discord and look for the Quest of the Week channel.
And for achievements for Celebrimbor’s Secret, this is what we have:
Not Finding Much
Complete the scenario with 0 cards underneath The Orcs’ Search.
Stay Close
Forced: Progress cannot be placed on Ost-in-Edhil locations in the staging area.